Co-founders Rachel Meinerding and Nicole Hendrix Herman explain why they built an awards show celebrating artists the industry rarely credits, and why this year's honorees Yoshitaka Amano and Eyvind Earle drew the most Lifetime Achievement votes; coming Saturday, October 24, at Lightbox Expo in Pasadena.
"The costume designers are winning awards," says Rachel Meinerding. "The production designers are winning awards, like, off the back of all of this artwork and that are coming from these talented men and women that are working in film, TV, and video games."
For the concept artists doing that work, there was no awards show at all. So in 2019, Meinerding and Nicole Hendrix Herman started one.
This Saturday, October 24, the Concept Art Awards return to the Pasadena Civic Auditorium for their eighth edition, presented by the Concept Art Association during LightBox Expo. This year's Lifetime Achievement Awards go to Yoshitaka Amano, the character and concept designer behind the Final Fantasy series, and, posthumously, Disney Legend Eyvind Earle, the color stylist who set the look of Sleeping Beauty. The show is open to anyone with an LBX badge.
Meinerding came to the cause from film costume departments, working on productions including Avengers: Age of Ultron, Captain America: The First Avenger, World War Z, and the Harry Potter franchise. Hendrix Herman is a four-time Emmy-winning producer and the executive director and co-founder of the BRIC Foundation, which works to increase representation for women and underrepresented groups in entertainment, media, and tech.
Credit where credit is due
Meinerding's husband, Ryan Meinerding, is head of visual development at Marvel Studios, and she saw up close "the fingerprints that are all over these costumes and characters." One of the only ways artists could get any notoriety, she noted, "is to kind of post online. And play the social media game. And Ryan finds that gross."
Hendrix Herman came at it from the other side. "In broadcast everybody wins an Emmy, right," she said. "I had won Emmys and I joke that they're for ugly commercials." Her friends, nearly all of them artists, would congratulate her. "And I'm like, well, you designed things that our grandchildren will talk about."
"I was able to get a promotion because of my awards," Hendrix Herman continued. "I was able to get a pay raise because of my awards." Some artists they know have used their awards, nominations, and judging credits to secure visas. "So for us, it is truly an act of love for the community."
Before their awards show existed, she pointed out, book signings "were really the only place that the public was able to acknowledge the contribution." When founders Bobby Chiu and Jim Demonakos started planning Lightbox Expo, the awards found a home at an event that, in Hendrix Herman's words, "feels like how our community feels as well."
From a third of a ballroom
The first show filled a third of a ballroom at the inaugural LightBox Expo… around 650 people. It had no professional categories, because professionals would not enter. "Because of the nature of artists being very introverted, they felt like they couldn't submit," Meinerding recalled. "It's like, that feels very boastful."
So the organizers ran a smaller show — fan art, student, and independent work, plus five Lifetime Achievement honors — and waited. Storyboard artists asked to be included after the first year. "It's literally just credit where credit is due," Meinerding said of the case they made to professionals. "It's not taking away. It's adding."
The two pandemic years moved the show online. Running virtually "meant that more international humans could be presenters," Hendrix Herman said, and "helped it grow in a way that it needed to." Since 2022, the show has been staged at the Pasadena Civic Auditorium with largely the same production crew.
Submissions hit a record last year, driven partly by tabletop artists who told the organizers "there was no longer a place for them to submit to." Tabletop work now has its own awards, shaped by an advisory committee led by illustrator Tyler Jacobson, and the storyboard category has expanded to two awards, developed with storyboard artists from the Art Directors Guild. Hendrix Herman noted that "almost every category of the show has been directly asked for by the community."
The show also runs year-round through a partnership with the BRIC Foundation. Students at Lawndale High School, a Title I school near LAX, take it as a class, working with the organizers from April on submissions, finalists, and presenters. Each show also includes anniversary tributes to films, series, and games from before the awards existed — work that, as Hendrix Herman put it, "should have won awards in the past."
How the work is judged
The submission window runs August to August. Organizers keep a spreadsheet of every film, show, and game released and reach out to the artists directly, because "a lot of artists need to be invited - they need to feel special," Hendrix Herman said. The independent category, known as the Beacon awards, and the student category draw the most entries, with the two new tabletop awards close behind this year.
Entries are screened to confirm they fall inside the window and are production concept art rather than marketing art or fan art. Finalists are asked one more time to confirm they have the right to share the work. "We never want to have anybody feel like it would hurt their career," she said. Generative AI work is barred outright, and screening for it is, she said, "a deep part of our qualifying process."
Judging is blind, run on the Award Force platform. "No one gets any names or anything like that on it," Meinerding explained. Each judge ranks a top seven, with seven points for first place down to one point for seventh, and the four highest totals become the finalists. The judges are working artists, often the previous year's winners. "We don't put any producers or directors or bosses or anything like that," Meinerding said. "It's all artists."
"A 25-year veteran isn't going to want to be judged by someone in their second year of their career," Hendrix Herman added.
The art, not the IP
Lifetime Achievement honorees are chosen by a vote of judges and members from a running list anyone can add to, and Amano and Earle drew the most votes. Some years, Meinerding said, the vote leans toward an artist tied to a beloved property, citing 2024 honoree Doug Chiang, Lucasfilm's vice president and executive creative director, and Star Wars. "Whereas this year," she said, "it feels really about the art rather than the IP."
Earle's selection, she said, "just shows that people still really care about the traditional art form and just the fundamental skill," adding that anyone working in animation "is going to be influenced in one way or another, whether it's direct or indirect, by the stuff that he did on Sleeping Beauty."
Concept artists, Meinerding noted, are now expected to turn in a "hyper-real finished rendering."
"I think it's cool that we're able to still celebrate artwork where it is a bit looser, where it is a little bit more blue sky," Meinerding said. "We're not looking to turn in a piece of artwork that looks exactly like it does on the screen. And that's what AI is able to do, right? Anyone can do that. But I think what these two individuals have is the ability to create artwork that is inspirational in a way that people can use it as a jumping off point."
In a statement, Amano said, "I'm very honored to receive this award. Since it recognizes creativity and the people who create, it makes me feel that everything I've done over the years has been worthwhile. I've always been influenced by American entertainment, so receiving an award like this in the United States is especially meaningful to me."
Earle died in 2000. "It has been 26 years since Eyvind's passing, and with each passing year, his influence and legacy seem only to grow," his estate said in a statement, adding, "Eyvind would have been deeply honored to receive the Concept Art Association's Lifetime Achievement Award." The Walt Disney Family Museum in San Francisco is bringing back its 2017 exhibition "Awaking Beauty: The Art of Eyvind Earle," opening this Friday, October 23, and running through April 18, 2027.
In the show's first year, Hendrix Herman recalled, "we were the first award a lot of those people had ever won. Right. So it's just been, these are humans that should have won a million awards."
Fewer jobs, fewer credits
Asked about the biggest challenge facing concept artists now, Meinerding pointed first to "employment, lack of employment." Generative AI is part of it, she said, but "there's also a lot of outsourcing stuff that is happening," including productions leaving California. "The animation industry is particularly hard hit by this as well."
AI has also made artists "more visible in a weird way," Meinerding said, because artists "were kind of the canary in the coal mine situation with gen AI. And they were the first to be outraged by this and asking questions."
The rest of the visibility problem, she said, is "more about corporate stuff than gen AI." Studios are pushing more uniform marketing messages "rather than calling out individual people," and the art book is changing with it. Marvel Studios, she said, has "always credited their artists. That has been like the gold standard for art books in the industry, but we're even starting to see some of the art books going away." Where an "Art of" book was once a genuine making-of, "now it feels like a lot of these are another part of the marketing piece. I think it's a missed opportunity personally, because I think a lot of these artists could grab whole other audiences."
Three unions sponsor the show every year, Hendrix Herman said: the Art Directors Guild, The Animation Guild, and Costume Designers Guild. "We don't speak for unions, but we listen," Hendrix Herman said.
The association has also lobbied in behalf of the community; it's as challenging as it sounds. Between 2022 and 2024, Hendrix Herman said, it brought artists and unions to Washington, D.C., to push for protections for individual artists against AI, and did similar work in California. The concept art, authors, cartoonist, and photography groups "all shared one lobbyist," she said, "versus OpenAI has a team of human beings, right? So, it really is not even David and Goliath."
"I wish that all of that art could just be seen and celebrated," Hendrix Herman concluded. A noble and shared sentiment indeed.
Read the full story on Animation World Network.